Tony Bingham

Top









Bottom

 

Adjudication

In my articles for Building magazine, I refer to cases concerning adjudication as case number X in my series. Some have asked for further details or a copy of that list, so here it is.

On Friday 1st May 1998, the Commercial Construction Industry took a great step forward. Jobs, quality of work, safety, and timely performance will now benefit from what is known colloquially as the Construction Act. Construction contracts, save for a few notable exceptions, will provide a statutory right to a 28 day dispute decision making process called Adjudication. The right arises in "The Housing Grants Construction and Regeneration Act 1996". It applies under that name in England Wales and Scotland; in Northern Ireland it applies since 1st June 1999.

This new Adjudication process is quite unlike anything that has held the ring between disputing parties in commerce. Existing Arbitration, Expert Determination, Conciliation, Mediation all require a consensual approach; both parties must agree to take their dispute to any one of those dispute processes. Not so New Adjudication. Parliament now provides that each Construction Contract shall provide that any party may call for this new referee. If there is a dispute between Developer and Main Contractor either party is entitled to forthwith call for this new person. The Adjudicators burden is to decide on the rights of the parties under the building contract and do so within the strict 28 day time frame. The "Decision" is binding forthwith. It can only be overturned, revised or confirmed in Arbitration (if the contract contains an Arbitration clause) or in litigation. It has "temporary finality" and is an announcement by an independent referee as to the rights of the contracting parties.

As for the procedure . . . how to adjudicate, it will often be that the machinery is laid down in the adopted Adjudication Rules or Standard Form Contract. By procedure we mean giving each party a reasonable opportunity of putting his case and dealing with that of his opponent. The watchword is fairness. Important too is not to lose sight of the adjudicator’s fundamental task: it is to decide the case put by the parties. No adjudicator can “make a case” for either party. No adjudicator is there to “find” the evidence, nor there to undermine a party’s case, nor there to dig for rights or duties. If an adjudicator investigates at all, it will be to clarify points of fact or law in the party’s case. It is vital that each party prepares his position on facts, evidence, rights and duties before he comes to adjudication. Important too that he has put his case already to the ‘other-side’. Remember, the adjudicator will have little time to do much more than decide upon the written case, as put. It is a contest between ‘A’ and ‘B’ not an investigation by the adjudicator.

Why Adjudication? British Construction offers its customers great flexibility. Many a construction project is designed and built on the hoof. Changes are inevitable ... and welcome. But change means change in price ... and programme. Disputes are ordinary. If the dispute is not efficiently managed it reduces itself and the project to conflict. Quality, time, safety suffers. And, occasionally it is true that some folk took advantage; the withholding of money was too easy. The New Adjudicator will quickly identify half baked claims; the building project will not be stymied by wrong headed nonsense.

The Construction Contracts in scope are not only large scale industrial and commercial building and civil engineering but include also the refurb to the High Street shop. Professional service contracts between Architect and Client are also classified as Construction Contracts. Excluded however are contracts between domestic house owners and the outfit building an extension. So too excluded is the supply only of building materials. Pity. Perhaps those areas will one day be brought into scope.

The construction industry welcomes this innovation. It has long since become tired of long drawn out squabbles. Parliament and cross party co-operation is to be congratulated. This will work.

Top Top

ADJUDICATION CASES

This list was last updated on 25 May 2005.

  1. MACOB -v- MORRISON (12 February 1999)
  2. RENTOKIL AILSA -v- EASTEND (Scottish Case) (March 1999)
  3. OUTWING CONSTRUCTION LTD -v- H RANDALL & SON LTD (15 March 1999)
  4. A STRAUME (UK) LTD -v- BRADLOR DEVELOPMENTS LTD (April 1999)
  5. A & D MAINTENANCE & CONSTRUCTION LTD -v- PAGEHURST CONSTRUCTION SERVICES LTD (June 1999)
  6. ALLIED LONDON & SCOTTISH PROPERTIES Plc -v- RIVERBRAE CONSTRUCTION LIMITED (Scottish Case) (July 1999)
  7. PROJECT CONSULTANCY GROUP -v- THE TRUSTEES OF THE GRAY TRUST (July 1999)
  8. JOHN COTHLIFF LTD -v- ALLEN BUILD NORTH WEST LTD (July 1999)
  9. PALMERS LTD -v- ABB POWER CONSTRUCTION LTD (August 1999)
  10. LATHOM CONSTRUCTION LTD -v- AB AIR CONDITIONING (October 1999)
  11. (1) HOMER BURGESS LIMITED -v- CHIREX (ANNAN) LIMITED (Scottish Case) (10 November 1999)
    (2) Homer Burgess Limited -v- Chirex (Annan) Limited (Scottish Case) (18 November 1999)
  12. BOUYGUES (UK) LTD -v- DAHL-JENSEN LTD (November 1999)
  13. SHERWOOD & CASSON LTD -v- MACKENZIE (November 1999)
  14. FASTRACK CONSTRUCTION LTD -v- MORRISON CONSTRUCTION LTD and anr. (January 2000)
  15. VHE CONSTRUCTION PLC -v- RBSTB TRUST CO LTD (January 2000)
  16. NORTHERN DEVELOPMENTS (CUMBRIA) LTD -V- J J NICHOL (January 2000)
  17. WORKPLACE TECHNOLOGIES PLC -and- E SQUARED LIMITED -and- MR J L RICHES (16 February 2000)
  18. GROVEDECK LIMITED -v- CAPITAL DEMOLITION LTD (24 February 2000)
  19. F W COOK LTD -v- SHIMIZU (UK) LTD (4 February 2000)
  20. SAMUEL THOMAS CONSTRUCTION LTD -v- J & B (28 January 2000)
  21. ABSOLUTE RENTALS LTD -v- GENCOR ENTERPRISES LTD (February 2000).
  22. NOLAN DAVIS LTD -and- STEVEN P CATTON (February 2000)
  23. ATLAS CEILING & PARTITION CO LTD -v- CROWNGATE (CHELTENHAM) LTD
  24. HERSCHELL ENGINEERING LTD -v- BREEN PROPERTY LTD (14 April 2000)
  25. BLOOR -v- BOWMER & KIRKLAND LTD (5 April 2000)
  26. BRIDGEWAY CONSTRUCTION LTD -v- TOLENT CONSTRUCTION (11 April 2000)
  27. TIM BUTLER CONTRACTORS LIMITED -v- MEREWOOD HOMES LIMITED (12 April 2000)
  28. STRATHMORE BUILDING SERVICES LIMITED -v- COLIN SCOTT GREIG t/a HESTIA FIRESIDE DESIGN (25 May 2000)
  29. JOHN MOWLEM & COMPANY PLC -and- HYDRA-TIGHT LTD (t/a Hevilifts) (06 June 2000)
  30. STIELL LIMITED -against- RIEMA CONTROL SYSTEMS LIMITED (Scottish Case) (23 June 2000)
  31. CHRISTIANI & SHAND -and- THE LOWRY CENTRE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY LIMITED (28 June 2000)
  32. NOTTINGHAM COMMUNITY HOUSING ASSOCIATION LIMITED -v- POWERMINSTER LIMITED (30 June 2000)
  33. KNS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES (BIRMINGHAM) LIMITED -and- SINDALL LIMITED (17 July 2000)
  34. BOUYGUES (UK) LTD -v- DAHL-JENSEN LTD (31 July 2000)
  35. R G CARTER LIMITED -v- EDMUND NUTTALL LIMITED (21 June 2000)
  36. ABB POWER CONSTRUCTION LTD -and- NORWEST HOLST ENGINEERING LTD (01 August 2000)
  37. WHITEWAYS CONTRACTORS (SUSSEX) LIMITED -and- IMPRESA CASTELLI CONSTRUCTION UK LIMITED (09 August 2000)
  38. GEORGE PARK -and- THE FENTON GRETTON PARTNERSHIP (24 July 2000)
  39. SHEPHERD CONSTRUCTION LIMITED -v- MECRIGHT LIMITED (27 July 2000)
  40. Ken Griffin & John Tomlinson T/a K & D CONTRACTORS -v- MIDAS HOMES LIMITED (21 July 2000)
  41. ELENAY CONTRACTS LIMITED - and - THE VESTRY (30 August 2000)
  42. UNIVERSAL MUSIC OPERATIONS LTD -v- FLAIRNOTE LTD & anr (24 August 2000)
  43. DISCAIN PROJECT SERVICES LTD -and- OPECPRIME DEVELOPMENT LTD (09 August 2000)
  44. EDMUND NUTTALL LTD -v- SEVENOAKS DISTRICT COUNCIL (14 April 2000)
  45. WOODS HARDWICK LTD -and- CHILTERN AIR CONDITIONING (2 October 2000)
  46. MAYMAC ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES LTD -and- FARADAY BUILDING SERVICES LTD (31 October 2000)
  47. KARL CONSTRUCTION (SCOTLAND) LTD -against- SWEENEY CIVIL ENGINEERING LTD (21 December 2000) (Scottish Case)
  48. ABB ZANTINGH LTD -V- ZEDAL BUILDINGS (12 December 2000)
  49. GLENCOT DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN CO LTD -and- BEN BARRETT & SON (CONTRACTORS) LIMITED (2 & 13 February 2001)
  50. RAINFORD HOUSE LIMITED (In Administrative Receivership) -v- CADOGAN LTD (13 February 2001)
  51. HOLT INSULATION LIMITED -and- COLT INTERNATIONAL LIMITED (2 February 2001) (Liverpool TCC)
  52. STAVELEY INDUSTRIES PLC (t/a EI.WHS) -and- ODEBRECHT OIL & GAS SERVICES LIMITED (28 February 2001)
  53. WATSON BUILDING SERVICES (13 March 2001) (Judicial Review)
  54. JOSEPH FINNEY PLC -and- GORDON VICKERS AND GARY VICKERS t/a MILL HOTEL (A FIRM) (07 March 2001)
  55. LPL ELECTRICAL SERVICES LTD v. KERSHAW MECHANICAL SERVICES LTD (02 February 2001)
  56. AUSTIN HALL BUILDING LTD -v- BUCKLAND SECURITIES LTD (11 April 2001)
  57. DISCAIN PROJECT SERVICES LTD -and- OPECPRIME DEVELOPMENT LTD (11 April 2001)
  58. FENCE GATE LTD -v- JAMES R KNOWLES LTD (31 May 2001)
  59. FAREBROTHER BUILDING SERVICES LTD -v- FROGMORE INVESTMENTS LTD (20 April 2001)
  60. BARR LTD v. LAW MINING LTD [15 June 2001] (Scottish Case) Lord Macfadyen
  61. BALLAST PLC v. BURRELL COMPANY (CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT) LIMITED [21 June 2001] (Scottish Case) Lord Reed
  62. RE A COMPANY (No.1299 Of 2001) [15 May 2001]
  63. MITSUI BABCOCK ENERGY SERVICES LIMITED v. (1) FOSTER WHEELER ENERGIA OY & (2) JANEY L MILLIGAN [13 June 2001] (Scottish Case) Lord Hardie
  64. RJT CONSULTING ENGINEERS LTD v. DM ENGINEERING (N.I.) LTD [9 May 2001) H H Judge MacKay
  65. WILLIAM NAYLOR,t/a POWERFLOATED FLOORS -v- GREENACRES CURLING [26 June 2001] (Scottish Case) Lord Bonomy
  66. S L TIMBER SYSTEMS LIMITED v. CARILLION CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [27 June 2001] (Scottish Case) Lord Macfadyen
  67. FAITHFUL AND GOULD LTD and ARCAL LIMITED (In Administrative Receivership) and ANGUS MARTIN, and WILLIAM KENNETH DAWSON [1 June 2001]
  68. BICKERTON CONSTRUCTION LIMITED and TEMPLE WINDOWS LIMITED [26 June 2001] (Her Honour Judge Frances Kirkham)
  69. BRITISH WATERWAYS BOARD for JUDICIAL REVIEW [05 July 2001] (Lord McCluskey)
  70. CITY INN LIMITED against SHEPHERD CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [17 July 2001] (Lord MacFadyen)
  71. C&B SCENE CONCEPT DESIGN LIMITED and ISOBARS LIMITED [ ] (Mr Recorder R Moxon Browne Q.C.)
  72. GIBSON RETAIL INTERIORS v. MAKRO SELF SERVICE [24 July 2001] H H Judge Richard Seymour QC.
  73. MAXI CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT LTD v. MORTONS ROLLS LTD [07 August 2001] Lord MacFadyen
  74. CYGNET HEALTHCARE plc v. HIGGINS CITY LIMITED [06/09/2000] H H Judge Thornton
  75. MILLERS SPECIALIST JOINERY COMPANY LIMITED and NOBLES CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [03 August 2001] H H Judge Gilliland Q.C.
  76. SINDALL LTD and SOLLAND & ors. [15 June 2001] HHJ Humphrey Lloyd QC
  77. MECRIGHT LTD and TA MORRIS DEVELOPMENTS LTD [22 June 2001] HHJ Richard Seymour QC
  78. PARSONS PLASTICS (RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENTS)LIMITED –and- PURAC LIMITED [13 August 2001] HHJ Frances Kirkham
  79. DURABELLA v.J JARVIS [ ] H H Judge Humphrey Lloyd QC
  80. DAVID McLEAN HOUSING CONTRACTORS LTD v. SWANSEA HOUSING ASSOCIATION LTD [27 July 2001] H H Judge Lloyd QC
  81. YARM ROAD LIMITED v. COSTAIN LIMITED [30 July 2001] HHJ Richard Havery QC (Novation)
  82. OAKLEY v. AIRCLEAR [04 October 2001] Etherton J (Common Assumption of JCT Contract) (Use of Stat. Demand)
  83. PAUL JENSEN LIMITED v. STAVELEY INDUSTRIES PLC [27 September 2001] Mr District Judge Donnelly (Fees of Adjudicator)
  84. STUBBS RICH ARCHITECTS v. W H TOLLEY & SON [8 August 2001] Mr Recorder Lane QC (Adjudicator’s Fees)
  85. JEROME ENGINEERING LIMITED v. LLOYD MORRIS ELECTRICAL LIMITED [23 November 2001] H H Judge Cockroft
  86. PRO DESIGN LTD v. NEW MILLENNIUM EXPERIENCE COMPANY LIMITED [26 September 2001] H H Judge Mackay
  87. SHIMIZU EUROPE LTD v. AUTOMAJOR LTD [17 January 2002] HHJ Richard Seymour QC
  88. LINEKER v. RIVIERA CONSTRUCTION [April 1999] HHJ Thornton
  89. ROBERT McALPINE v. PRING ST HILL [October 2001] HH Judge Moseley
  90. KARL CONSTRUCTION (SCOTLAND) LIMITED against SWEENEY CIVIL ENGINEERING (SCOTLAND) LIMITED [22 January 2002] Lord Marnoch (Scottish Case- Inner House, Court of Session)
  91. C&B SCENE CONCEPT DESIGN LTD –AND- ISOBARS LTD [31 January 2002] (Supreme Court of Judicature Court of Appeal)
  92. SOLLAND INTERNATIONAL LIMITED –AND- DARAYDAN HOLDINGS LIMITED [15 February 2002] H H Judge Richard Seymour Q.C.
  93. TOTAL M AND E SERVICES LIMITED –and- ABB BUILDING TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED (formally ABB STEWARD LIMITED) [25 February 2002] H H J David Wilcox
  94. RJT CONSULTING ENGINEERS LTD v. D M ENGINEERING (NI) LTD [08 March 2002] Court of Appeal
  95. EDMUND NUTTALL LIMITED –and- R G CARTER LIMITED [21 March 2002] HH Judge R Seymour QC
  96. CHAMBERLAIN CARPENTRY & JOINERY LTD –and- ALFRED McALPINE CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [25 March 2002] HH Judge R Seymour QC
  97. BRITCON v. LINCOLNFIELDS H H Judge Thornton
  98. WATKIN JONES & SON LTD v. LIDL UK Gmbh H H Judge Moseley QC (No dispute?)
  99. ASHLEY HOUSE v. GALLIERS SOUTHERN H H Judge Seymour (Enforcement stayed/Insolvency/ Paid in)
  100. PARSONS PLASTICS (Research and Development) LTD –and- PURAC LTD [12 April 2002] Court of Appeal (Set-off)
  101. BALFOUR BEATTY CONSTRUCTION LTD –and- THE MAYOR AND BURGESSES OF THE LONDON BOROUGH OF LAMBETH [12 APRIL 2002] H H Judge Humphrey Lloyd QC
  102. NORDOT V SIEMENS [April 2002] H H Judge Gilliland
  103. HARWOOD v. LANTRODE [November 2001] HH Judge Seymour
  104. R G CARTER v. EDMUND NUTTALL [April 2002] H H Judge Bowsher
  105. CLARKE CONTRACTS v. THE BURRELL [January 2002] Sheriff James Taylor
  106. BARRY D TRENTHAM LIMITED v. LAWFIELD INVESTMENTS LIMITED [May 2002] Lord Drummond Young
  107. IMPRESA CASTELLI SpA v. COLA HOLDINGS LTD [02 May 2002] HH Judge Thornton QC
  108. CANARY RIVERSIDE DEVELOPMENT v. TIMTEC INTERNATIONAL [09 November2000] Mr DKR Oliver QC
  109. WATKIN JONES & SON LIMITED v. LIDL UK GmBh [27 December 2001] HH Judge Humphrey Lloyd QC
  110. EARLS TERRACE PROPERTIES LIMITED and WATERLOO INVESTMENTS LIMITED [14 February 2002] H H Judge Seymour Q.C.
  111. QUALITY STREET PROPERTIES v. ELMWOOD (GLASGOW) LTD Sheriff Court
  112. GILLIES RAMSAY DIAMOND against PJW ENTERPRISES LIMITED [04 May 2001] Lady Paton
  113. SIM GROUP LTD v. NEIL JACK [05 June 2002] Lord Clarke
  114. ISOVEL CONTRACTS V. ABB TECHNOLOGIES LTD [30 November 2001] Mr Simon Barry QC, Chancery
  115. VA TECH WABAG UK LIMITED v. MORGAN EST (SCOTLAND) LTD [30 May 2002] Lord Drummond
  116. J T MACKLEY & Co. Ltd v. GOSPORT MARINA LIMITED [03 July 2002] H H Judge Seymour
  117. HERSCHELL ENGINEERING LTD v. BREEN PROPERTY LTD (No.2) [28 July 2000]
  118. EDINBURGH ROYAL JOINT VENTURE [02 August 2002] T G Coutts QC
  119. GIBSON v. IMPERIAL HOMES [27 February 2002] H H Judge Toulmin, CMG, QC
  120. FAB-TEK ENGINEERING LTD v. CARILLION CONSTRUCTION LTD [March 2002]
  121. THE CONSTRUCTION CENTRE GROUP LIMITED v. THE HIGHLAND COUNCIL [23 August 2002] Lord Macfadyen: Scottish case Outer House, Court of Session
  122. BOVIS LEND LEASE LTD v. TRIANGLE DEVELOPMENT LTD [2 November 2002] HH Judge Thornton QC
  123. LEVOLUX A.T. LIMITED v FERSON CONTRACTORS LIMITED
  124. SKANSKA CONSTRUCTION UK LTD v. THE ERDC GROUP LTD and JOHN HUNTER
  125. BALLAST v. BURRELL
  126. GUARDI SHOES v. DATUM CONTRACTS
  127. DEBECK DUCTWORK v. T & E ENGINEERING
  128. BALDWINS v. BARR LTD
  129. A. v. B [17 December 2002] Lord Drummond Young: Scottish Case Outer House, Court of Session.
  130. CARILLION v. DAVENPORT ROYAL DOCKYARD H H Judge Bowsher Q.C.
  131. FERSON CONSTRUCTION LTD v. LEVOLUX LIMITED [22 January 2003] Court of Appeal
  132. JOINERY PLUS LIMITED v. LAING LIMITED [21 January 2003] H H Judge Thornton Q.C.
  133. A J BRENTON (t/a Manton Electrical Components) v. JACK PALMER [19 January 2003] H H Judge R Havery Q.C.
  134. COWLIN CONSTRUCTION v. CFW ARCHITECTS [15 November 2002] H H Judge Frances Kirkham
  135. PICARDI (Architects) v. MR & MRS CUNIBERTI [19 December 2002] H H J Toulmin CMG.QC.
  136. TRY CONSTRUCTION LTD v. ETON TOWN HOUSE GROUP LTD [28 January 2003] H H J David Wilcox
  137. HART BUILDERS (EDINBURGH) LTD v. ST ANDREW LTD [20 August 2003] Sheriff Isobel Anne Poole, (Scottish Case)
  138. MARTIN GIRT v. PAGE BENTLEY [12/04/02] H H Judge David Wilcox
  139. DUMARC BUILDING SERVICES LTD v. Mr SALVADOR-RICO H H Judge Hull Q.C.
  140. HITEC POWER PROTECTION BV v. MCI WORLDCOM LTD [15/08/02] H H Judge R Seymour Q.C.
  141. VAUGHAN ENGINEERING LTD v. HINKINS & FREWIN LTD [03/03/03] Lord Clarke
  142. PEGRAM SHOPFITTERS LIMITED v. TALLY WIEJL (UK) LIMITED [14/02/03] H H Judge Thornton Q.C.
  143. HART BUILDERS (EDINBURGH) LIMITED v. ST ANDREW LIMITED [10/01/03] Sheriff Principal Iain Macphail Q.C.
  144. HARVEY SHOPFITTERS LTD v. ADI LTD [06/03/03]
  145. R DURTNELL & SONS LIMITED v. KADUNA LIMITED [19/03/03]
  146. TRUSTEES OF THE HARBOUR OF PETERHEAD v. LILLEY CONSTRUCTION LIMITED H H Judge R Seymour Q.C.
  147. JAMIL MOHAMMED v. DR RICHARD BOWLES
  148. ST ANDREWS BAY DEVELOPMENT LIMITED v. HBG MANAGEMENT LIMITED (AND Mrs Janey Milligan – Second Respondent) [20/03/03] Lord Wheatley, Outer House, Court of Session.
  149. HILLS ELECTRICAL v. DAWN CONSTRUCTION LTD
  150. DEKO SCOTLAND LIMITED v. (1) Edinburgh Royal Joint Venture, (2) Morrison Construction Ltd, (3) Balfour Beatty Construction Ltd, (4) Haden Young Ltd [11 April 2003] Lord Drummond Young, Outer House, Court of Session
  151. CONSTRUCTION CENTRE GROUP LIMITED v. THE HIGHLAND COUNCIL [11 April 2003] delivered by Lord Hamilton, Inner House, Court of Session.
  152. BECK PEPPIATT LTD –and- NORWEST HOLST CONSTRUCTION LTD [20 March 2003] Mr Justice Forbes
  153. COMSITE PROJECTS LIMITED –and- ANDRITZ AG [30 April 2003] H H Judge Frances Kirkham
  154. PRING & ST HILL v. C J HAFNER (t/a Southern Erectors) [31 July 2002] H H Judge Humphrey Lloyd Q.C.
  155. GALLIFORD (UK) LIMITED (t/a Galliford Northern) v. MARKEL CAPITAL LIMITED [12 May 2003]
  156. CITY INN LIMITED v. SHEPHERD CONSTRUCTION LIMITED [20 May 2003] delivered by Lord Justice Clerk, Inner House, Court of Session.
  157. ORANGE E B S LIMITED v. ABB LIMITED [22 May 2003] H H Judge Frances Kirkham
  158. SHIMUZU EUROPE LIMITED v. LBJ FABRICATIONS LIMITED [29 May 2003] H H Judge Frances Kirkham
  159. COSTAIN LTD v. WESCOL STEEL LTD [24 January 2003] H H Judge Havery QC
  160. RSL (SOUTH WEST) LIMITED v. STANSELL LIMITED [16 June 2003] H H Judge R Seymour QC
  161. LOVELL PROJECTS v. LEGG & CARVER
  162. BRACKEN v. BILLINGHURST HHJ Wilcox
  163. HURST STROES & INTERIORS v. M. L. EUROPE
  164. ABBEY DEVELOPMENTS v. PP BRICKWORK LTD [04 July 2003]
  165. HIGHLAND COUNCIL v. CONSTRUCTION CENTRE GROUP LTD [01 August 2003]
  166. GW INTEGRATED BUILDING SERVICES v. G&M Floorlayers [18 July 2001]
  167. Van Oord ACZ Limited and Harbour & General Works Ltd Joint Venture v. The Port of Mostyn Limited [10 Sept 2003]
  168. AMEC Capital Project Ltd v. WHITEFRIARS CITY ESTATE LTD [19 Sept 2003]
  169. J W HUGHES Building Contractors Ltd v. GB METALWORK LTD [03 Oct 2003]
  170. THOMAS FREDRIC’S (Construction) Limited v. KEITH WILSON [21 Oct 2003]
  171. DEAN & DYBALL Construction Ltd v. KENNETH GRUBB ASSOCIATES LTD [28 Oct 2003]
  172. SIMONS CONSTRUCTION LIMITED v. AARDVARK DEVELOPMENTS LTD [29 Oct 2003]
  173. RUPERT MORGAN Building Services Ltd v. DAVID JERVIS & HARRIET JERVIS [12 Nov 2003]
  174. TALLY WIEJL (UK) LTD v. PEGRAM SHOPFITTERS LTD [21 Nov 2003]
  175. GALLIFORD TRY Construction Ltd v. MICHAEL HEAL Associates Ltd [01 Dec 2003]
  176. PRENTICE ISLAND LTD v. CASTLE CONTRACTING LTD [15 Dec 2003]
  177. COSTAIN LTD v. STRATHCLYDE BUILDERS LTD [17 Dec 2003]
  178. GILLIES RAMSAY DIAMOND v. PJW ENTERPRISES LTD [24 Dec 2003]
  179. LONDON & AMSTERDAM PROPERTIES LIMITED v. WATERMAN PARTNERSHIP LIMITED [15 Dec 2003] H H Judge David Wilcox
  180. IDE CONTRACTING LIMITED v. R G CARTER CAMBRIDGE LIMITED [16 Jan 2004]
  181. THE HIGHLAND COUNCIL [23 Jan 2004]
  182. CITEX PROFESSIONAL SERVICES LIMITED V. KENMORE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED [28 Jan 2004]
  183. RSLS (SOUTH WEST) v. STANSELL [04 Sept 2003] The Vice-Chancellor Sir Andrew Morritt and Lord Justice Peter Gibson
  184. SPECIALIST CEILING CONTRACTORS v. ZVI CONSTRUCTION [March 2004]
  185. WESTMINSTER BUILDING COMPANY LTD v. ANDREW BECKINGHAM [20 February 2004] H H Judge Thornton Q.C.
  186. BRANLOW LTD v. DEMI-MASTER DEMOLITION
  187. AMEC CAPITAL PROJECTS LIMITED v. WHITEFRIARS CITY ESTATE LIMITED
  188. BARNES ELLIOTT v. TAYLOR WOODROW [20 June 2003]
  189. ML EUROPE PROPERTY LIMITED v. HURST STORES AND INTERIORS LIMITED [20 SEPT 2003]
  190. RITCHIE BROTHERS (PWC) LIMITED v. DAVID PHILIP (COMMERCIALS) LIMITED [14 April 2004] Lord Eassie – Outer House, Court of Session
  191. BUXTON BUILDING CONTRACTORS LTD v. GOVERNORS OF DURAND PRIMARY SCHOOL [12 March 2004] H H Judge Thornton QC
  192. HURST STORES AND INTERIORS LTD v. ML EUROPE PROPERTY LTD [01 April 2004]
  193. CONOR ENGINEERING LIMITED v. LES CONSTRUCTIONS INDUSTRIELLES DE LA MEDITERRANEE (CNIM) SA [05 April 2004]
  194. BAL (1996) Ltd v. TAYLOR WOODROW CONSTRUCTION LTD [23 Jan 04]
  195. AWG Construction Services Limited v. Rockingham Motor Speedway Limited [05 April 2004]
  196. M J Gleeson Group Plc v. Devonshire Green Holding Limited [19 March 2004]
  197. Alstom Signalling Limited (Trading as Alstom Transport Information Solutions) v. Jarvis Facilities Limited [28 May 2004]
  198. McAlpine PPS Pipeline Systems Joint Venture v. Transco Plc [12 May 2004]
  199. William Verry v. North West London Communal Mikvah [11 June 2004]
  200. Connex South Eastern Limited v. M J Building Services Group PLC [25 June 2004]
  201. Rossco Civil Engineering Ltd v. DWR Cymru Cyfngdic [15 July 2004]
  202. Murray Building Services v. Spree Developments [30 July 2004]
  203. Melvill Dundas Limited (In Receivership), (2) Colin Peter Dempster and (3) Thomas Merchant v. George Wimpey UK Limited [22 October 2004]
  204. AMEC Capital Projects Limited v. Whitefriars City Estates Limited CA [28 October 2004]
  205. Emcor Drake & Scull Ltd v. Costain Construction Ltd [29 October 2004]
  206. A&S Enterprises Limited v. Kema Holdings Limited [27 July 2004]
  207. CIB Properties Limited v. Birse Construction [19 October 2004]
  208. Collins (Contractors) Limited v. Baltic Quay Management (1994) Limited [07 December 2004]
  209. Bryen & Langley Limited v. Martin Rodney Boston [4 November 2004]
  210. GPN Limited (In Receivership) v. O2 (Uk) Limited [22 October 2004]
  211. William Verry (Glazing Systems) v. Furlong Homes Ltd [13 January 2005]
  212. Trustees of the Stratfield Saye Estate v. AHL Construction Limited [06 December 2004]
  213. Connex South Eastern Ltd v. M J Building Services Group plc CA [01 March 2005]
  214. Harvey Shopfitters Limited v. ADI Limited CA [13 November 2003]
  215. Amec Civil Engineering Ltd v. Secretary of State for Transport [11 October 2004]
  216. Balfour Beatty Construction v. Serco Limited [21 December 2004]
  217. David John Cartwright v. Miss Lydia Fay [09 February 2005]
  218. Amec Civil Engineering Ltd v. Secretary of State for Transport CA [17 March 2005]
  219. Palmac Contracting Limited v. Park Lane Estates Limited [22 March 2005]
  220. Ritchie Brothers (PWC) Limited v. David Philp (Commercials) Limited [24 March 2005]
  221. Carillion Construction Limited v. Devonport Royal Dockyard [26 April 2005]
  222. Geris Handelsgesellschaft GmbH v. Les Construction Industrielles de la Mediterrannee S.A. [11 February 2005]

Top Top

This website is designed and maintained by Web Designers
©   A. W. Bingham, 1998-2008.  All rights reserved.